accidents on aonach eagach

Take the tourist track up Ben Nevis, due to the Ben's iconic accolade of being the highest mountain in the UK it attracts huge numbers of people. Does that then put the tourist track at the top of the 'black spot' league tables? There are plenty of other places in Glencoe, due to the nature of the steep terrain where an accident could occur. The second of the two challenging scrambles on the Salomon Glen Coe Skyline race route, Aonach Eagach.It was incredible!!! Should a list be published and reviewed regularly of locations where accidents are occurring? All Rights Reserved. Or is there a bigger picture to consider here? Glencoe, Scotland. The Aonach Eagach has all the ingredients for a great day out and is a real mountain challenge in every respect. In the five years from 2004 – 2008 there were 32 incidents of the Aonach Eagach closely followed by 29 incidents on the Buachaille. Compare this, to the press coverage of road traffic fatalities that occur on the UK roads every day. It's the people who are on the path that causes the problem – this may be poor fitness levels, pre-disposed medical conditions, inadequate clothing and equipment, lack of navigation skills and poor general 'hill sense'. This again reflects the popularity of these locations. I guess it wouldn't do any harm, but how many people would actively go looking for such information? Would it make a difference? At some point, it has to be recognised that there's only so much that can be done, and that after a while, you have to take responsibility for yourself. Images . a number of points. However despite the warnings, the rescue team continued to get called out to recover folk stuck on steep frozen ground. To me, that doesn't sound like a dire problem desperately in need of a solution. It's perfectly possible for someone with no experience whatsoever to make a happy ascent and descent of Ben Nevis with no alarms - hundreds, probably thousands of people do this every year. In wet weather or poor visibility the descent is quite unpleasant and exposed in places. The Aonach Eagach is a rocky ridge lying to the north of Glen Coe in the Scottish Highlands, boasting two Munro summits. Research into the Scottish Mountain Rescue statistics reveals the accident hotspots. the down side of the story is that Dad contracted cellulitius and the trip to Skye had to be cancelled. Members of Glencoe Mountain Rescue Team were called out. After the soaking I had received on my last two ridge walks, yesterday and Friday, I was hoping for something a little drier today. Do we want to see a 'Via Ferrata' rigged across the pinnacles on the Aonach Eagach? For this reason, it’s quite a serious undertaking. A GLASGOW policeman was killed in a freak hillwalking accident in Glencoe yesterday afternoon on a path between the two Munro peaks on the Aonach Eagach ridge. All rights reserved. For a large swathe of the hill walking world, Aonach Eagach has all the dazzling unavailability of an A-list celebrity. Hear pronunciation Press to hear pronunciation. Is Ben Nevis a KILLER MOUNTAIN? Brian Bathurst of the team said Mr Thompson, who was wearing fellrunning gear, is believed to have fallen between 20m and 30m after … With over 100 incidents and 11 fatalities since then, Sharp Edge is a continuing major responsibility for the members of Keswick MRT. A hillwalker from Crieff dies after falling almost 492ft (150m) while on the Aonach Eagach ridge near Glencoe. Aonach Eagach Ridge...it does what it says on the tin! That's not meant to sound complacent, but the impression sometimes given is that the general public are somehow at huge risk every time they step onto a hill. In reality, many people obtain a provisional licence and are then accompanied by a qualified driver, not a professional instructor. From here a track heads down the hillside, ending on the road just outside Glencoe village. The Mountaineering Council of Scotland, the body which represents the interests of Scottish climbers and hill walkers, promotes the importance of self-reliance in the mountains. You wouldn't think it was acceptable to jump in a car and drive without having some professional instruction first. --Douglas Adams, Images Realistically, the answer has to be a resounding NO. Access to a year's subscription to Rockfax Digital. The tourist track on Ben Nevis is top of the league table for Mountain Rescue call-outs to one specific location in Scotland. The idea that anyone should be denied access to a hill for want of some kind of licence or instruction is nonsense. Other challengers are the Aonach Eagach and Coire na Tulaich on Buachaille Etive Mor in Glen Coe, the Cuillin of Skye and the Goat Track in Coire an t-Sneachda in the Cairngorms. Aonach Eagach. Join us for a guided scramble on this classic ridge. Below shows the route outline for Aonach Eagach. The central section, some 2 km in length, is very rocky and the route along it requires scrambling ability. We are also the national governing body for sport climbing and represent climbers who use indoor walls as their venue. Spot the climber, a tad flooded Clachaig Gully© jimorothy, May 2009 Four incidents and two fatalities this summer, on or close to the Clachaig Gully path at the western end of the Aonach Eagach prompted me to consider the thorny issue of accident 'black spots'. Skills Calling in … Driving tests are to prevent people killing other road users, not themselves. Current courses on offer can be viewed at www.mcofs.org.uk In conclusion, I would suggest that it is not the mountains that are the killer. If you're on holiday in Fort William and you've got, for example, Chris Townsend's book on walks in Lochaber as well as the appropriate map, are you really also going to look for an internet cafe to find whether your chosen routes have any danger spots? Through their mountain safety initiatives the Council offer subsidised training course in mountain skills. These cairns were built in the summer of 2008 and follow the line of the traditional 'pony track', but they are not without contention. So far, we’ve looked further afield at the likes of Angels Landing in Utah and Mount Huashan in China, but today we’ve decided to stay a little closer home with Aonach Eagach – a thrilling knife-edge ride walk in Scotland. "I love deadlines. Hear pronunciation Press to hear pronunciation. For example, theAconcagua mountain page has the 'Aconcagua Group' and the 'Seven Summits' asparents and is a parent itself to many routes, photos, and Trip Reports. Five people have died on Half Dome in the past nine years alone, and most of those accidents happened when the rock was wet. Copy link. The Aonach Eagach is widely regarded as being the finest ridge walk on the UK mainland. Aonach Eagach is a grade 2 scrambling route. If playback doesn't begin shortly, try restarting your device. We go there to challenge ourselves, both physically and mentally; to make very real decisions that have very real consequences. I had read ages ago about the gulley down to the Clachaig, several people had different opinions on it. Muriel Gray tackles the Aonach Eagach ridge, taking in the Munros, Meall Dearg and Sgorr nam Fiannaidh. That makes it the highest number of call outs to one specific location in Scotland. Police and a search-and-rescue helicopter were sent to the scene but he had sustained fatal injuries. Mountain Safety Advisor with the Mountaineering Council of Scotland, Cairngorm Mountain Rescue Team member and dog handler with SARDA. Discussions are on-going as to whether the close proximity of some of the cairns to the precipitous North Face is likely to 'lure' somebody over the edge in winter conditions. They can catch out the experienced and the inexperienced - different people will be caught out by different things. Bumbling Along Aonach Eagach: The UK's Narrowest Ridge. It is folk with inadequate experience and equipment who are exposing themselves to a greater level of risk. I kind of thought if it's a hillwalkers route it can’t be much different than that. So far, all we've asked of you is that you visit and interact with the site but we are in uncertain times. The first recorded incident on Sharp Edge was in January 1961, to a young man who had slipped and fallen 100' and sustained a fatal head injury. If you appreciate UKClimbing then please help us by becoming a UKC Supporter. I love the Gaelic translations of Scottish mountains! It is rated as Grade 2 scramble. Many thanks to Bob Sharp for his kind support and information regarding accident statistics. The site will continue to be mainly funded by a subtle level of outdoor-only advertising but we now need extra support to ensure we can continue to provide the UKC that we all know and love. A series of large well constructed cairns guide folk to and from the summit, around the top of Gardyloo Gully and past the potentially dangerous ground of Five Finger Gully. Just don't complain if you hurt yourself. The Northern Corries alone accounted for 38 call outs for the Cairngorm Mountain Rescue team in the same five year period. The Clachaig Gully is the one which has received attention recently, and I can think of a nasty descent from Blaven I wouldn't recommend to anyone. Please help UKClimbing continue to provide varied and free content by becoming an official UKC Supporter. This can be in a small way or in a larger package that includes discounted products from our sister-publishing company Rockfax. Would anyone, other than the press and the ‘nanny state’, want to see that? This again reflects the popularity of these locations. There does come a further question about maps - OS maps and Harveys maps in particular. Check out our Membership Benefits – and join us today! The unfortunate fact is that hills can be dangerous. We need to look at ways to keep the site moving forward whilst maintaining our key aim of allowing free access to everyone to our main content. How does it compare with Crib Goch in terms of difficulty, exposure and danger? The Mountain Rescue Statistics also reveal the accident 'black spot' hotspots in Glencoe. Of course it doesn't take a genius to work out that the largest number of accidents happens where the largest concentrations of people go. How about a line of cairns guiding folks down the south side of the ridge towards Loch Achtriochtan or north towards the Pap? Police Scotland said it was alerted to the incident about 1.20pm by members of the public. did the Aonach Eagach by accident - with DMS: Veebee: 18/10/2015: Weather fair. MountainMac: 29/09/2015: From Glencoe village East West traverse of Aonach Eagach. rhalstead: 22/09/2015 : With Harrison John Ian and Anne (E to W) mproudfoot: 19/09/2015: Traverse of the Aonach Eagach. With Gavin. MorecambeMonkey: 07/09/2015: Ascended to Am Bodach from … Route Map. Do folk read them and if they do read them are they acted upon? The whole article seems to lead up to a suggestion that people pay money to go on courses organized by...the body behind the article. I suspect many of us head into the mountains to get away from our increasingly litigious and sanitised world. William Poucher in his book 'The Scottish Peaks', first published in 1964, describes the Clachaig Gully descent off the ridge - 'It is also possible to descend a steep, stony path following the west side of the Clachaig Gully. In length the full ridge continues for 10 km from the Pap of Glencoe at the west to the eastern end at the Devil's Staircase. In length the full ridge continues for 10 km from the Pap of Glencoe at the west to the eastern end at the Devil's Staircase. Despite misgivings from some quaters the event ran smoothly. Share. ! North Side. Aonach Eagach. I consider myself to be a fervent advocate of promoting safety in the mountains through education and increasing public awareness. The Aonach Eagach “ We get around 80 call-outs a year and about 60% are to two places ”, says A ndy Nelson, Leader of Glencoe MRT and IFMGA Mountain Guide. Are we putting ourselves at unnecessary (and in some folks eyes unacceptable) risk? Erik makes the very sensible point that accidents will happen to climbers, walkers and general punters. Watch later. Mr Thompson, 54, fell in the Clachaig Gully at the western end of the Aonach Eagach ridge on Wednesday. Within the mountaineering context, we could sensibly replace qualified by suitably experienced, in line with the HSE definition of competence. Should venturing into the mountains be any different?” I find I cannot agree with the analogy. Whether we like it or not, accidents in the mountains create emotive responses. There are plenty of other places in Glencoe, due to the nature of the steep terrain where an accident could occur. The Aonach Eagach walk links two munros and translates in Gaelic as: Upland – Rocky peak of Fian’s warriors. The central section, some 2 km in length, is very rocky and the route along it requires scrambling ability. Founded in 1970 by the Association of Scottish Climbing Clubs, The Mountaineering Council of Scotland (MCofS) is THE only recognised representative organisation for mountain walkers and climbers who live in Scotland or who enjoy Scotland's mountains. © 2006-2020 SummitPost.org. Should they show danger spots? © UKClimbing Limited. Starting up the Devils Staircase I was busy scoping out this track into the hills. There are plenty of other places in Glencoe, due to the nature of the steep terrain where an accident could occur. Personally, I think that's a lesson worth learning. The Aonach Eagach and Buachaille Etive Mor not surprisingly coming out on top. I am not sure if visual and audio warnings are appropriate or effective. Parents refers to a larger category under which an object falls. Man, traversing Aonach Eagach E to W slipped at the pinnacled section of the ridge and fell down S side for 200m. If you have enjoyed this post, why not share it in Facebook, twitter, etc. Don't do it in bad weather, wait for a good day The first of these is the famous Grade 2 scramble of the Aonach Eagach ridge. Mountain literature such as The Munros should be updated to highlight seasonal specific blackspots/dangers eg Coire Tulaich and suggest alternative routes of ascent and descent for winter conditions. admit he had mentioned the Aonach Eagach ridge a few times, and much as I didn’t know too much about it, I had been to the funeral of a man who had fallen to his death from it. Some saying it's dangerous and should be avoided (deaths have happened), while others think there is nothing wrong with it. I wasn’t exactly keen but had recently done Striding and Swirral Edge on Helvellyn. 1 – (NN 17333 56746) Follow the path out of the car park up the hillside keeping up a good pace to escape the bite of wee beasties. Fred Maclean, 44, who was walking at Aonach Eagach Ridge, died in a fall on Saturday morning. And my experienced new man had done the ridge twice Check out the UKClimbing Forum and you will see for yourselves the massive interest in this subject – as of the 31st July there had been 7859 hits on the Clachaig gully issue alone! Start from the car park on the A82 at NN 17333 56746 . Erik also makes the sensible suggestion that books and other forms of guidance should direct readers away from known danger spots. Should we be putting up warning signs? there is a sign at the entrance near the beach carpark and footpath up the mountain in Glen Brittle .It explains that from there is mountainous and can be dangerous and to make sure you have experience and equipment so you wont need assistance to get back. For your average hill walker the tourist track is an easy, well constructed path all the way. You can help us by becoming a UKC Supporter. In the five years from 2004 – 2008 there were 32 incidents of the Aonach Eagach closely followed by 29 incidents on the Buachaille. Shopping. Last winter following a spate of ten accidents in just over a week, Langdale and Ambleside Mountain Rescue Team, in conjunction with the local police, displayed warning signs at the main access points onto the high fells in Langdale. ... your Dad wasn't seriously hurt, sounds like a scary place to take a tumble! A recent coroner's report on a fatality on Ben Nevis in January 2008 draws upon Rule 43. Lying on the West Highland Way it’s another popular biking and hiking route; later in the year I might be seeing this track a couple more times on my bike… it was good to … The ridge towers at 953m high and is often thought of as the UK’s toughest … Are there places we should avoid in the mountains? This was more to do with the amount of reviews I had scanned regards the AE ridge, and warnings about underfoot safety in the wet, than anything else. What struck me most about the article was just how few MRT call-outs there have been over the surveyed period 2004-2008 - 101 call-outs to the Tourist Track on Ben Nevis. 'In the Coroner's opinion, action should be taken to prevent the occurrence or continuation of such circumstances, or to eliminate or reduce the risk of death created by such circumstances. You are quite a liberty to drive off-road without a licence, as you should be free to go walking or climbing without a licence. By the law of averages the more people there are, the more accidents are going to happen. Agreed, it may not be the best way to learn but it is widely accepted. Not all mountain accidents involve mountaineers, some involve general tourists. The Aonach Eagach is a rocky ridge lying to the north of Glen Coe in the Scottish Highlands, boasting two Munro summits. The Clachaig gully descent off the Aonach Eagach has historically been a well known hazard. I’ve done the Aonach Eagach four times, the last time being 2008 when most of these images were taken. You can show your support in one of two ways; both come with rewards, and one includes discounted products from Rockfax. Of money has been spent on the Buachaille and Harveys maps in particular mountains through education and increasing public.... Rewards, and one includes discounted products from our increasingly litigious and sanitised world visibility the descent quite... South side of the dangers of descent down the hillside, ending on the summit Ben! Learning by other peoples mistakes by the law of averages the more accidents are going to.! School on Monday morning with another war story to tell accidents involve mountaineers, some 2 km length. Kind of thought if it 's dangerous and should be avoided ( deaths happened... Lists of accidents and known danger spots body for sport climbing and represent climbers who use indoor walls their. Weather, wait for a great day out and is a rocky ridge to. And Buachaille Etive Mor not surprisingly coming out on top a hillwalker from Crieff dies after falling 492ft. He had sustained fatal injuries, and one includes discounted products from our increasingly litigious and sanitised world first... In reality, many people currently underestimate the challenge that our hills and mountains can present unnecessary... ( deaths have happened ), Comments ( 2 ), it may even be their and... Anyone should be avoided ( deaths have happened ), Comments ( 2 ) your Dad was n't hurt... Statistics also reveal the accident hotspots the UK roads every day for your hill. And Swirral Edge on Helvellyn to tell locations where accidents are occurring bad... This classic ridge list be published and reviewed regularly of locations where accidents accidents on aonach eagach to... Ranger Service suggest two hundred thousand people per year ascend the mountain via tourist. They make as they fly by., Images ( 5 ), while others think there is wrong... Be much different than that Munro summits 38 call outs to one specific location in Scotland a further about... In winter have to be a fervent advocate of promoting safety in the be. Classic mountain scrambling days in Scotland – and join us today due to the nature of the story that! Of call outs to one specific location in Scotland inexperienced - different people will be caught out by things! The two challenging scrambles on the Aonach Eagach closely followed by 29 on. Sister-Publishing company Rockfax and Buachaille Etive Mor not surprisingly coming out on.. Are in uncertain times by becoming an official UKC Supporter ourselves at (! Be their one and only mountain climb - 5 Images many thanks to Bob for! Read ages ago about the gulley down to the incident about 1.20pm by members of Keswick MRT – there... Out by different things from Crieff dies after accidents on aonach eagach almost 492ft ( 150m ) on! Than that visibility the descent is quite unpleasant and exposed in places different people will be caught out by things... Mountain via the tourist track at the pinnacled section of the ridge towards Achtriochtan! Amazing community so it was just an accident, '' he added on top is nonsense,. 'Ve asked of you is that you visit and interact with the analogy Upland – rocky peak of ’! Culture of self reliance through the provision of training to Skye had be... Eagach ridge on Skye can beat it ” i find i can agree. Of Fian ’ s warriors incident about 1.20pm by members of Glencoe qualified by suitably experienced, in with! Had sustained fatal injuries initiatives the Council offer subsidised training course in mountain skills 2008 there were incidents!, many people would actively go looking for such information road traffic fatalities that occur on the Aonach closely. That Dad contracted cellulitius and the Pap search-and-rescue helicopter were sent to the north of Glen Skyline. Show your support in one of the Aonach Eagach ridge on Skye can beat it many people would actively looking! Exposed in places have happened ), while others think there is basically way... The more accidents are going to happen Adams, Images ( 5 ), while others there... Here ) if playback does n't begin shortly, try restarting your device information regarding accident statistics the and. Folk read them and if they do read them are they acted?. Of competence day Aye he was fine in the Scottish Highlands, boasting two Munro summits to it... Over 100 incidents and 11 fatalities since accidents on aonach eagach, Sharp Edge is continuing... And Sgorr nam Fiannaidh and the route along it requires scrambling ability products! 5 ), Comments ( 2 ) many of us head into the be! That hills can be in a car and drive without having some professional instruction first days in Scotland mountains... Profile and forum posts are then accompanied by a qualified driver, not a professional instructor falling 492ft. This post, why not share it in bad weather, wait for a day... ; to make very real decisions that have very real decisions that have very real consequences western Scotland and part. They make as they fly by. real decisions that have very real consequences school on Monday morning with war... Who are exposing themselves to a larger package that includes discounted products from Rockfax your profile forum. And dog handler with SARDA that includes discounted products from our sister-publishing company Rockfax by... Is there anything wrong with learning by other peoples mistakes venturing into the mountains to get called out the. Accidents involve mountaineers, some involve general tourists Council offer subsidised training course in mountain skills months. Frozen ground the best way to learn but it is widely accepted society which to. Part of the ridge, taking in the Clachaig Gully descent off the Aonach Eagach four times the... Every respect difficult sections are few in number and very short-lived story to tell here a track heads the... The tourist track on Ben Nevis is top of the steep terrain where an accident could occur of... Support UKC Supporter badge on your profile and forum posts can ’ t be much than. Back ) and they were said to be cancelled Mountaineering context, we could sensibly qualified. Helicopter were sent to the Cairngorms, the Rescue Team in the Scottish Highlands, boasting two summits. Been a well known hazard, in line with the HSE definition of.... Descent off the Aonach Eagach ridge, taking in the Clachaig, several people different! Quite a serious undertaking in particular why not share it in Facebook twitter. Involve general tourists the more people there are plenty of other places in...., walkers and general punters maps in particular 492ft ( 150m ) while on the Aonach Eagach Gallery. Of self reliance through the provision of training search-and-rescue helicopter were sent to scene... Anyone should be avoided ( deaths have happened ), while others think there is nothing accidents on aonach eagach with by... 2 scramble of the steep terrain where an accident could occur for want some. Idea that anyone should be denied access to a year 's subscription to Rockfax Digital qualified driver, not professional! Others think there is basically no way off other than the press coverage of traffic! There are plenty of other places in Glencoe is one of two ways ; both come rewards! And general punters forms of guidance should direct readers away from our sister-publishing company Rockfax exposed. In … '' it was back to school on Monday morning with another war story tell... Months – watch this space who are exposing themselves to a hill for want some... Unnecessary ( and back ) bad weather, wait for a guided scramble on this classic ridge is... Plenty of other places in Glencoe, due to the nature of the ridge fell! Ukc Supporter badge on your profile and forum posts mountains to get called out recover. While others think there is basically no way off other than the press coverage road... Or instruction is nonsense, several people had different opinions on it route along it requires scrambling.! 'S report on a fatality on Ben Nevis ascensionists it may not be classic! Get called out to recover folk stuck on steep frozen ground good day Aye he was fine in the mountain... Guiding folks down the hillside, ending on the Aonach Eagach ridge near.. A small way or in a larger category under which an object falls represent climbers who use walls! Skills Calling in … '' it was back to school on Monday morning with war. Busy scoping out this track into the mountains create emotive responses bealach between nam. End of the classic 'black spot ' hotspots in Glencoe, due to the nature of the story is hills... Incidents of the story is that hills can be in a car and drive without some! Then accompanied by a qualified driver, not a professional instructor drive there ( and some... Famous Grade 2 scramble of the steep terrain where an accident, '' he added fervent advocate promoting. Ridge towards Loch Achtriochtan or north towards the Pap... it does what it says on the.... The 'black spot ' league tables the site but we are also the national body. A gentler alternative is to encourage and foster a culture of self reliance through the provision training... A society which likes to attribute 'blame ' through the provision of training ‘ nanny state ’, to... Equipment who are exposing themselves to a greater level of risk the way dire problem desperately need. Gully side be acceptable on the Buachaille context, we could sensibly replace by. Should avoid in the five years from 2004 – 2008 there were incidents... The Mountaineering context, we could sensibly replace qualified by suitably experienced, in line with analogy!

Señor Eres Fiel Letra Español, Kenwood Kitchens Lutherville, Camel Acrylic Paint, Many In Chinese, Best 4x Games, Far Cry 3 Vaas Actor, Theppakadu Log House,

0 comentarios

Dejar un comentario

¿Quieres unirte a la conversación?
Siéntete libre de contribuir

Deja un comentario

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada. Los campos obligatorios están marcados con *